2022 Winter Qualifying Exam in Algebra (AI-generated)

Problem 1.


Let . Prove that multiplication of left cosets,

is well defined.

Proof.


Suppose and . Then and for some . Since is normal, . Therefore

Thus , so the product does not depend on the chosen representatives.

Problem 2.


Let , and assume that is the only nontrivial proper normal subgroup of . If satisfies

prove that .

Proof.


Let . The action of on the left cosets of gives a homomorphism

Its kernel is normal in and is contained in . The map cannot be injective because

when . It is not trivial because the coset action is transitive on more than one coset. Hence is a nontrivial proper normal subgroup, so the given result implies . Thus . Since has index and is proper, necessarily .

Problem 3.


Prove that every group of order is a semidirect product of proper nontrivial subgroups.

Proof.


Let be the number of Sylow -subgroups. Then or .

If , the Sylow -subgroup is normal. Let be any Sylow -subgroup, of order . Then and

so .

If , the four Sylow -subgroups contain eight distinct nonidentity elements. Only three nonidentity elements remain. Every Sylow -subgroup has order , so its three nonidentity elements must be precisely those remaining elements. Thus the Sylow -subgroup is unique and normal. If is a Sylow -subgroup, then again and . Hence in this case as well.

Problem 4.


Suppose but . Prove that is not diagonalizable.

Proof.


Put

Then and , so is an eigenvector with eigenvalue . The vector is a generalized eigenvector of rank .

If were diagonalizable, then so would . For a diagonalizable operator , one has

as is immediate from a diagonal representation. But here while , a contradiction. Thus is not diagonalizable.

Problem 5.


Let be a prime ideal of . If satisfies the descending chain condition on ideals, prove that is maximal.

Proof.


The quotient is an integral domain. It is also Artinian by the descending-chain hypothesis. Let . The chain

stabilizes, so for some . Hence for some , and

Since is a domain and , we get . Thus every nonzero element of is invertible, so is a field. Therefore is maximal.

Problem 6.


Let

Prove that cannot be expressed as a product of irreducible elements.

Proof.


The units of are exactly and . Indeed, a unit of is a nonzero rational constant, and both it and its reciprocal lie in only when they are .

Every positive-degree divisor of in has degree and therefore has the form with . But for every integer ,

and both factors lie in and are nonunits. Thus no positive-degree divisor of is irreducible.

If were a finite product of irreducibles, the sum of their degrees would be , so one factor would have positive degree. That factor would be a positive-degree divisor of , contradicting the preceding paragraph. Hence no factorization into irreducibles exists.

Problem 7.


Determine the structure, as a product of cyclic groups, of the unit group of

Proof.


Over ,

The quadratic factor is irreducible because its discriminant is

which is not a square modulo . The Chinese remainder theorem gives

The multiplicative group of a finite field is cyclic, so the unit group is

Problem 8.


Let be a primitive th root of unity.

(a) Give an explicit bijection between and .

(b) Find the degree of

over .

Proof.


(a) The bijection sends to the automorphism

(b) The exponents are the nonzero quadratic residues modulo . Put

The subgroup of quadratic residues, of order , fixes . A nonresidue sends it to the sum over the five nonresidues. Since

and the classical quadratic Gauss-period calculation gives

the two periods are the roots of , whose discriminant is . Thus

up to the choice of square root. It is not rational, so its orbit has size and

Problem 9.


For each item, give an example or prove none exists.

(a) Finite-order elements in a group such that has infinite order.

(b) A surjective group homomorphism .

(c) A real matrix satisfying .

(d) Fields such that and are Galois but is not.

Proof.


(a) In the infinite dihedral group

both and have order , while has infinite order.

(b) No. The image of the divisible group under a homomorphism is divisible, while the only divisible subgroup of is . More explicitly, if , then for every , so is divisible by every positive integer and must be zero. It follows that is the zero map.

(c) No. Taking determinants would give

which is impossible over .

(d) Take

Both successive extensions are quadratic and therefore Galois. The top extension over is not normal because it does not contain the conjugate of .