2024 Fall Qualifying Exam in Algebra (AI-generated)

Problem 1.


Let be a group and let

Prove that if and only if is abelian.

Proof.


Suppose first that is abelian. Then is abelian, so every subgroup, including , is normal.

Conversely, suppose is normal. For ,

must lie in . Hence . Taking gives for every . Thus every two elements commute, and is abelian.

Problem 2.


Let be prime and . Prove that no group of order is simple.

Proof.


Let be the number of Sylow -subgroups. Then

Therefore is either or . If , the unique Sylow -subgroup is a nontrivial proper normal subgroup.

Suppose . Conjugation gives a nontrivial homomorphism

If were simple, its kernel would be trivial, so would embed in . But the highest power of dividing is , whereas with divides . Lagrange's theorem makes such an embedding impossible. Hence is not simple.

Problem 3.


Let be a commutative ring with identity. Assume is a PID. Prove that is a field.

Proof.


Because a PID is an integral domain, and therefore are integral domains. Let . Since is a PID,

for some . The polynomial divides both the nonzero constant and the polynomial . Since degrees add in a polynomial ring over a domain, must be constant, so .

Because , we have for some . Comparing the coefficients of gives for the leading coefficient of . Thus is a unit. Hence , so there exist such that

Setting gives , so is a unit. Every nonzero element of is a unit, and therefore is a field.

Problem 4.


(a) Let be commutative and let . Prove that

(b) Prove that is not maximal in .

Proof.


(a) Consider the composite quotient map

It is surjective. Its kernel consists precisely of those whose class modulo belongs to the ideal generated by , which is equivalent to . The first isomorphism theorem gives the desired isomorphism.

(b) By part (a),

But

in . The quotient therefore has zero divisors and is not a field. Consequently is not maximal.

Problem 5.


Prove that a commutative ring satisfies the ascending chain condition for ideals if and only if every ideal of is finitely generated.

Proof.


Assume first that every ideal is finitely generated. Given an ascending chain

the union is an ideal. Write . All finitely many generators lie in some , so

Thus for all .

Conversely, assume ACC and let be an ideal. If were not finitely generated, choose , and after choosing , choose

Then

would be an ascending chain that never stabilizes, contradicting ACC. Therefore every ideal is finitely generated.

Problem 6.


Let be an integral domain, let be an -module, and let . If and are torsion-free, prove that is torsion-free.

Proof.


Suppose and satisfy , with . In the quotient,

Since is torsion-free, , so . Now the equality holds inside the torsion-free module . Since , it follows that . Thus is torsion-free.

Problem 7.


Let be a complex matrix whose characteristic polynomial has no repeated roots, and suppose all its roots are roots of unity.

(a) Prove that for some .

(b) Can one necessarily take ?

(c) Does (a) remain true without separability?

Proof.


(a) A characteristic polynomial with distinct roots splits over , so is diagonalizable. Write

Each is a root of unity. If is the least common multiple of their orders, then for every , and hence .

(b) No. For , the matrix satisfies the hypotheses, but .

(c) No. Consider

Its only eigenvalue is the root of unity , but its characteristic polynomial is not separable. For every ,

Problem 8.


Let be a field such that every odd-degree polynomial in has a root in . If is finite and , prove that is even.

Proof.


Suppose instead that is odd. Choose . By the tower law,

Thus the degree of the minimal polynomial of over , namely , is an odd integer greater than . By hypothesis, this minimal polynomial has a root in . An irreducible polynomial over having a root in must be linear, a contradiction. Therefore is even.

Problem 9.


Let be Galois of degree , and suppose there are two distinct fields strictly between and . How many strict intermediate fields are there in total?

Proof.


Let , so . A group of order is either cyclic or isomorphic to . If were cyclic of order , it would have a unique subgroup of order and hence only one strict intermediate field. The hypothesis therefore forces

The proper nontrivial subgroups of this group are exactly the one-dimensional subspaces of the two-dimensional vector space . Their number is

By the Galois correspondence, there are exactly six strict intermediate fields.

Problem 10.


Let be a finite Galois extension, where and . Suppose some satisfies . Prove that

Proof.


Put . The element satisfies

over . Since , this shows

On the other hand,

Thus fixes . But it does not fix , because . Hence , so . Combining both inequalities gives .