2013 Spring Comprehensive in Analysis

Problem 1.


Show that the sequence defined recursively by

converges and find its limit.

Proof.


Let

The fixed points of satisfy

so

and hence

Since , all terms are greater than . Indeed, if , then

Also,

Thus, for , we have .

Since , then is increasing and bounded below by . In every case, converges.

Let . Passing to the limit in

gives

Since every term is greater than , the limit must be the fixed point , not . Therefore

Problem 2.


Show that the series

converges pointwise to a continuous function on .

Proof.


For each fixed , we have

Since

converges, the given series converges absolutely, hence pointwise, for every fixed .

It remains to show that the limit function is continuous. Let . On the compact interval ,

Because

the Weierstrass -test implies that the series converges uniformly on . Each function

is continuous, so the uniform limit on is continuous on .

Since every point of lies in some interval , the pointwise limit is continuous on all of .

Problem 3.


Prove the following integral test. Assume that is a positive and decreasing function on . Then the series

converges if and only if the sequence is bounded, where

Proof.


Since is decreasing, for every integer and every , we have

Therefore

Summing from to gives

First assume that converges. Then the partial sums on the right are bounded, so

is bounded.

Conversely, assume that is bounded. Then there exists such that

for all . From the inequality above,

Thus the partial sums of are bounded. Since all terms are positive, the partial sums are increasing, so the series converges. Adding the single term does not affect convergence. Hence

converges.

Problem 4.


Let be continuous and satisfy

Prove or disprove: is uniformly continuous on .

Proof.


The statement is true.

Let . Since

there exists such that

whenever .

Because is continuous on the compact interval , it is uniformly continuous there. Hence there exists such that if and

then

Let

Suppose .

If at least one of and is at most , then both and lie in , so

If both and , then

Therefore is uniformly continuous on .

Problem 5.


Let be an increasing function on . Let denote the set of all discontinuity points of on . Prove that is at most countable.

Proof.


We prove the result for points in ; the two endpoints can add at most two more points.

For , since is increasing, the one-sided limits

exist. Also

Thus is discontinuous at only if

For each interior discontinuity point , choose a rational number such that

This is possible because is dense in .

We claim that different discontinuity points give different rationals. Indeed, if , then by monotonicity,

Therefore the intervals

are disjoint. Hence .

Thus the map

from the set of interior discontinuities into is injective. Since is countable, the set of interior discontinuities is countable. Adding the endpoints, is at most countable.

Problem 6.


Evaluate the integral

where

and is the area element on .

Proof.


Use spherical coordinates on the unit sphere:

where and . The area element is

Therefore

Thus

The first integral is

For the second integral, put . Then and

Hence

Therefore

Thus

Problem 7.


Let be a bounded function on . Prove or disprove each statement.

(a) If is Reiemann integrable on , then is Reiemann integrable.

(b) If is Reiemann integrable on , then is Reiemann integrable.

Proof.


(a) The statement is false.

For example, on , define

Then

for all , so is Riemann integrable. However, every interval contains both rational and irrational numbers, so on every subinterval the supremum of is and the infimum of is . Hence the upper integral of is and the lower integral of is . Therefore is not Riemann integrable.

(b) The statement is true.

Let

By assumption, is Riemann integrable. Since is bounded, is bounded. The function

is continuous on every compact interval. By the standard theorem that a continuous function composed with a Riemann integrable function is Riemann integrable, is Riemann integrable. But

Therefore is Riemann integrable on .

Problem 8.


Let be a twice differentiable function on such that

and

Prove that there exists such that

Proof.


Apply the Mean Value Theorem to on the interval . There exists such that

Since , this gives

Now apply the Mean Value Theorem to on . There exists such that

Therefore

Since is twice differentiable, is continuous on and differentiable on . By Rolle's Theorem applied to on , there exists such that

Problem 9.


Let be the metric space consisting of all continuous functions on with metric

Let be a differentiable function on with

for all . Define by

for all and . Prove that has a unique fixed point in .

Proof.


First, if , then is continuous, so . Thus maps into itself.

For and , the Mean Value Theorem applied to gives

Taking the maximum over , we get

Thus is a contraction with contraction constant .

The metric space with the sup metric is complete. Therefore, by the Banach Fixed Point Theorem, has a unique fixed point in .